In this publication
Three key takeaways
- Start with the net amount needed, then check documented shareholder advances available for repayment and the available capital dividend account balance.
- A taxable dividend may trigger a corporate tax refund; compare that refund with the personal tax arising from the payment.
- A return of capital can have different consequences for different shareholders; a specific planning opportunity may also merit examination.
Buying a home, helping a child or repaying a debt may require a large withdrawal. The first question is straightforward: how much do you need after tax? The money belongs to the corporation, even if you own all its shares. You therefore need to decide how it should be paid to you.
First check what you can receive without new tax
If you have lent personal funds to your corporation, it can generally repay the outstanding principal without creating new income. The amount must be confirmed from the advances and repayments already made. Interest, if any, remains taxable.
Your private corporation may also have a capital dividend account, or CDA. This tax calculation includes, among other things, the non-taxable portion of certain gains realized on its investments. An available balance may permit a dividend free of personal tax if you reside in Canada. The balance must be checked, and the required federal and Québec documents must be prepared before payment.
Plan for the tax on the rest
A taxable dividend is a common way to withdraw accumulated profits. The tax you pay depends on your other income and the type of dividend. You therefore need to arrange a payment large enough to fund your project and pay that tax.
The payment may also allow the corporation to recover part of the tax it has paid on its investments. That refund belongs to the corporation; you still pay tax on your dividend. Both effects must be calculated together to determine the actual cost of the withdrawal.
For a holding corporation that mainly owns investments, we generally do not suggest using salary to withdraw a large amount. Salary triggers personal tax and applicable contributions without triggering the tax refund. Its deduction must also be supported by the services performed. In an active business, however, salary or a bonus can be compared with a dividend.
Consider a return of capital
Another possibility is to repay part of the capital recognized for tax purposes for the shares, known as paid-up capital. This amount can be very different from the corporation’s current value. A properly established repayment can be made without a taxable dividend, but the holder’s tax cost of the shares must also be checked.
Paid-up capital is allocated equally among the shares of the same class: each share therefore has the same average paid-up capital. Tax cost may nevertheless differ from one shareholder to another. The same repayment can therefore be tax-free for one shareholder and trigger a capital gain for another if it exceeds the tax cost of that shareholder’s shares.
This gain may sometimes qualify for the capital gains exemption if the shares and the shareholder meet the conditions. Shares of a corporation that mainly holds passive investments generally do not qualify. Alternative minimum tax must also be assessed.
Calculate the net amount and choose the timing
Suppose you need $200,000 after tax. The corporation owes you $60,000 and can pay you a capital dividend of $40,000. If the conditions are met, you already have $100,000 without new personal tax. You therefore still need another $100,000 after tax.
With tax of 40% on the additional dividend, approximately $166,667 would have to be paid to provide that $100,000 net amount. The corporation’s total cash outflow would be approximately $266,667. This rate is used only to illustrate the calculation. Tax on any sale of investments and the corporation’s tax refund must also be considered.
If your project allows it, spreading dividends over two years may reduce your personal tax. This saving must be compared with the cost of temporary financing and your expected income. A loan from the corporation also requires analysis: it can be included in your income even if you intend to repay it.
Have the options reviewed before withdrawing the money
Before transferring the funds, have the available net amount, expected taxes and documents to be signed established. A combination of repayments and dividends may be beneficial.
If you purchased your shares from another shareholder, specific planning related to their tax cost may also be considered.
Sources and tax details
Key references
CDA: subsections 83(2) and 89(1) ITA; section 502 of Québec’s Taxation Act. CRA, Income Tax Folio S3-F2-C1.
Tax refund: section 129 ITA. CRA, T2 Corporation Income Tax Guide, chapter 6.
Capital: subsections 84(4) and 89(1), subparagraph 53(2)(a)(ii), subsection 40(3) and section 110.6 ITA.
Salary and loans: paragraph 18(1)(a), section 67 and subsection 15(2) ITA.
The displayed date is separate from the content review date. This article provides general information based on the stated sources and scope of review. It is not tax advice tailored to your situation. The rules, their conditions and administrative positions must be reviewed before taking action.
APPLY THIS TO YOUR SITUATION
Support for your plans.
Salary, dividends, major withdrawals or retirement: coordinate your corporation’s taxes with your personal needs.
Rollovers, holding corporations, amalgamations and wind-ups: organize transactions around your goals and their tax consequences.
Calculate safe income, analyze dividends and prepare distributions before a sale, purification or reorganization.
