In this publication
Three key takeaways
- Choosing shares or assets changes the risks assumed and future deductions; this decision should be made before signing the agreement.
- Plan the borrower and cash flows together to determine whether interest qualifies for deduction and whether that deduction can actually be used.
- A minority investment requires arrangements for distributions and your eventual exit; its structure differs from acquiring the entire business.
Before buying a business, three decisions must be made together: what you are buying, how to finance it and the structure that will allow you to repay the debt. Buying a minority interest or taking control does not offer the same possibilities. The goal is to preserve as much after-tax cash as possible to finance the acquisition without weakening the business.
Are you buying the corporation or its assets?
Buying shares means becoming an owner of the corporation. It retains its history, contracts and debts. If an audit later reveals unpaid taxes for an earlier year, the corporation may have to pay them. Your investment then bears the consequences, even if the mistake was the seller’s.
Buying assets means acquiring specific property: equipment, inventory, customer relationships or a building. You choose which items to take over. However, you must check debts secured by those assets and contracts to be transferred, including the lease and permits.
The choice also changes future deductions. A machine may be worth $100,000 even though only $20,000 remains to be deducted for tax purposes. Buying the shares generally does not reset that deduction to $100,000. Buying the machine directly for that price generally establishes a new tax cost of $100,000, deductible under the capital cost allowance rules. The same purchase price can therefore produce different after-tax outcomes.
Plan the financing and choose who will make the purchase
Financing generally combines a down payment, a bank loan and, sometimes, an amount the seller agrees to receive later. For example, a $1,000,000 price could be financed by a $200,000 down payment, a $600,000 bank loan and $200,000 payable to the seller. This example is not a financing standard. Payment dates must be negotiated based on the amounts the business can actually generate.
More than the price must be financed: transaction costs, inventory, wages and future investments also require money. The budget must cover interest and principal repayments after taxes and operating needs. Principal repayments are not deductible in themselves. Deferring part of the payment to the seller may ease the early years, but you must plan how to pay that amount when it becomes due.
You must also choose who will make the purchase. Is the down payment in your personal account or in a holding corporation? If it is already in a corporation, having that corporation make or finance the acquisition may avoid first paying you a taxable personal dividend. A corporation created for the purchase can also facilitate the involvement of partners and the financing arrangements. The loan, the purchase and the flow of funds must be designed together.
In an asset purchase, the corporation buying the assets can operate them and directly bear the loan. Operating revenue and interest are then in the same place. In a share purchase, a difficulty arises: the acquired corporation earns the profits, while the person or corporation buying its shares bears the debt. The flow of money between them must be arranged, and you must determine where the interest will actually reduce tax.
The deduction requires, among other things, an obligation to pay reasonable interest and the use of the funds to earn income. For shares, there must be credible reasons to expect dividends one day, meaning amounts distributed to shareholders. According to the Canada Revenue Agency, immediate payment is not essential. Expecting only a salary or a profitable resale is not enough. Keep the loan documents, statements and proof of payment to the seller; refinancing requires checking the link between the debt and its use again.
Adapt the structure to a majority or minority acquisition
If you buy the entire business: bring the debt and the profits together. An acquiring corporation can borrow, buy the shares and then receive dividends from the business to repay its loan. The money can therefore be used to service the debt before being paid to you personally. Any taxes that may apply between corporations must nevertheless be calculated.
This addresses the movement of money, but not necessarily the use of the deduction. Each corporation calculates its tax separately. The dividend received by the acquiring corporation may be deducted from its taxable income: it brings cash without creating the taxable income against which its interest can be used. It may therefore accumulate tax losses while the acquired business continues to pay tax on its profits.
At 100% ownership, an amalgamation after the purchase is one solution to consider. It combines the acquiring corporation and the business into a single corporation, which bears the debt and earns the revenue. Eligible interest can then reduce that corporation’s taxable profits. The amalgamation must be planned with the bank and advisers, taking account of contracts and tax rules; it is not automatically the best solution.
Returning to the example: on an $800,000 debt balance at 6%, annual interest is $48,000 before any reduction in the balance. At a purely illustrative tax rate of 25%, a fully usable deduction produces savings of $12,000. The net interest cost is then $36,000. If the deduction remains unused, those savings do not help finance the repayment. The location of the debt can therefore change the true cost of the purchase.
If you hold a majority interest alongside other shareholders: take their rights into account. Buying 60% of the voting shares does not give you access to all the cash. Dividends and reorganizations must respect the rights of other shareholders, bank covenants and legal requirements. An amalgamation may be possible, but its effect on ownership interests and debt must be negotiated. Financing must be arranged from the outset, even if you control the business.
If you hold a minority interest: arrange access to cash and choose who will borrow. With 20% of the shares, you generally do not decide on dividends alone. A business can make profits and reinvest everything: your loan still has to be repaid even if you receive nothing. The shareholders’ agreement must therefore address distributions, financial information and your exit, within the limits of the business’s needs and commitments.
Buying through your corporation can be attractive if it already has the down payment and regular dividends can repay its debt before a personal distribution. However, intercorporate tax and the use of interest deductions must be quantified. The percentage held and the rights attached to the shares affect the treatment of dividends. The acquiring corporation will not automatically be able to use its interest against the profits of the business in which it holds 20%.
A personal purchase may be preferable if eligible interest immediately reduces other income for federal tax purposes. This advantage must be weighed against the personal tax on the dividends used for repayment. In Québec, investment expenses are limited by reference to investment income: a high salary is not enough to obtain the full provincial tax saving. A portion may have to be used in another year.
Finally, the choice must take resale into account: the personal capital gains exemption may benefit an eligible individual, but not their corporation selling the shares. For a minority shareholder, the best structure therefore results from comparing available net dividends, usable tax savings and the outcome on resale. The structure chosen to buy 100% does not automatically carry over to a 20% purchase.
Sources and tax details
Tax reference points and sources
Financing: BDC, “Comment financer l’acquisition d’une entreprise”.
Interest: ITA, paragraph 20(1)(c); Québec Taxation Act, section 160. CRA, Folio S3-F6-C1, paragraphs 1.35, 1.44, 1.63.1 and 1.69–1.70 (administrative position).
Québec, investment expenses: Québec Taxation Act, sections 313.10 and 336.6; Revenu Québec, line 260.
Structure: ITA, section 87, subsections 112(1), 55(2), 186(1) and 186(4). Capital cost allowance: ITA, paragraph 20(1)(a). Resale: ITA, subsection 110.6(2.1).
Also to be checked before signing: prior taxes and the seller’s warranties; tax losses on an acquisition of control (ITA, subsections 111(4) and 111(5)); GST/QST and the election applicable to an asset purchase (Excise Tax Act, subsection 167(1); Act respecting the Québec sales tax, section 75).
The displayed date is separate from the content review date. This article provides general information based on the stated sources and scope of review. It is not tax advice tailored to your situation. The rules, their conditions and administrative positions must be reviewed before taking action.
APPLY THIS TO YOUR SITUATION
Support for your plans.
Rollovers, holding corporations, amalgamations and wind-ups: organize transactions around your goals and their tax consequences.
Transaction structure, financing, share eligibility and net proceeds: analysis tailored to sellers, buyers and successors before commitments are made.
