In this publication

Three key takeaways

  1. Tax treatment depends on intention, conduct and financing; holding Bitcoin does not automatically mean that you are carrying on a business.
  2. Business losses follow different rules from capital losses; a deductible loss does not translate into an equal tax refund.
  3. Documenting transactions and losses from the outset helps establish the facts needed to assess your particular situation.

Article dated December 18, 2025, adapted for online reading. Factual details and the scope of the judgment clarified on September 5, 2026.

Background and facts of the Amicarelli case

In 2017, Ms. Jeanette Amicarelli, an Air Canada employee, made repeated purchases of Bitcoin through the Canadian platform QuadrigaCX. Her account balance disappeared in December 2017, before the broader crisis that affected the platform in 2018. She claimed a non-capital loss of $505,142.58, which included invested funds, interest and other costs. The Canada Revenue Agency denied the loss. The Tax Court of Canada had to answer two questions: had the taxpayer actually suffered the alleged loss, and was it on income or capital account? The Court ultimately recognized a loss of $473,241.74 for 2017. [Amicarelli, judgment and paragraphs 1–4, 8, 14–15 and 32–38.]

The tax issue: speculation or passive investment?

The decision raises a familiar investment tax question: did the loss arise from commercial activity or from an investment held on capital account? Under Canadian tax law, profit from a business, including an adventure in the nature of trade, is fully included in income. The corresponding losses follow the rules governing business losses and, where applicable, non-capital losses. For the 2017 taxation year at issue, one-half of a capital gain was included in income, while an allowable capital loss could generally only be used against taxable capital gains. Characterization is therefore crucial: it determines both the treatment of profits and how losses may be used. [Income Tax Act, sections 3, 9, 38 and 111; definition of “business” in subsection 248(1).]

Criteria for speculation under Canadian tax law

To decide the issue, the judge applied the case-law criteria that distinguish a trading transaction from an investment held on capital account. These criteria include the following. They are discussed in paragraphs 43–46 of the judgment, drawing in particular on Friesen v. Canada, [1995] 3 S.C.R. 103.

The taxpayer’s intention: was the asset acquired with the objective of making a quick profit on resale?

Conduct and concrete steps: do the taxpayer’s actions resemble those of an active trader—such as transaction frequency, market monitoring and time spent—and are they consistent with the stated intention?

Connection with the taxpayer’s expertise or occupation: where a transaction relates to the taxpayer’s professional activities, it is more likely to generate business income. Ms. Amicarelli worked in air transportation, with no direct connection to cryptocurrency, so this factor carried less weight.

Nature of the asset: some assets provide no regular income or personal benefit in the circumstances in which they are held. This may support the inference that they were acquired for profitable resale. The judge noted that Bitcoin pays no interest or dividends and that no personal use or benefit was established in this case. The nature of the asset must nevertheless be considered alongside the other facts.

Financing and holding period: costly borrowing and an objective of resale in the near term may indicate an adventure in the nature of trade. For Ms. Amicarelli, the Court considered the second mortgage, credit-card advances and RRSP withdrawals, while also taking rising prices into account.

These criteria must be applied flexibly, and no single factor is decisive. Even one transaction can be an adventure in the nature of trade. Transaction frequency may be an additional indicator, but the analysis considers all the facts. The objective factors help determine whether the taxpayer’s actions support the stated intention to make a profit. [Amicarelli, paragraphs 43–46.]

Application to cryptocurrency in Amicarelli

Amicarelli applies established principles distinguishing income from capital to cryptocurrency. The evidence showed that Ms. Amicarelli intended to profit from Bitcoin’s appreciation in 2017. She made regular purchases and monitored both her account and the market. The Court considered it immaterial whether she had made more or fewer than 100 transactions: her conduct went beyond occasional participation and resembled that of a trader. [Amicarelli, paragraphs 47–51.]

Bitcoin’s characteristics also mattered. Under the definition agreed upon by the parties for the appeal, Bitcoin is intangible digital property that can, among other things, be bought, sold, exchanged, lent or stolen. Holding it does not, by itself, produce interest or dividends. In this case, Ms. Amicarelli did not use her Bitcoin for personal transactions or as part of a wider financial-instrument structuring strategy. The judge found that she was seeking the anticipated appreciation. These observations concern the facts of this case and do not resolve the treatment of every activity involving cryptoassets. [Amicarelli, paragraphs 5–7 and 52–54.]

Another significant factor was the scale of the taxpayer’s financial commitments. Ms. Amicarelli took out a second mortgage at a high interest rate, used her credit cards and withdrew her RRSP savings to buy cryptocurrency. The Court viewed this costly financing as consistent with her belief that she would achieve a positive financial outcome. The fact that she had not sold any Bitcoin before the loss was not decisive: holding an asset for most of a year of strong appreciation could remain consistent with a profit-making objective. [Amicarelli, paragraph 55.]

The decision: a loss on income account and symmetrical treatment

After assessing the evidence as a whole, the Court allowed the appeal. On a balance of probabilities, it found that Ms. Amicarelli had incurred the amounts recognized and suffered a loss from a fraud whose exact mechanism remained unknown. Her activities fell within the definition of “business” in subsection 248(1) of the Income Tax Act. The matter was referred back to the Minister for reassessment recognizing a non-capital loss of $473,241.74 for 2017. That treatment allows the loss to be used under the applicable income-computation and loss-carryover rules; it does not turn the loss into an equal tax refund. [Amicarelli, judgment and paragraphs 35–38 and 57.]

The judgment also sheds light on the symmetrical treatment of profits and losses. The judge explained that theft or fraud can be a business risk, and a resulting loss may be deductible where it is incidental to the business. To the extent that profits earned in an exuberant market are fully taxable, losses arising from the same activity must receive consistent treatment. Characterization nevertheless remains a factual question: the existence of fraud or the size of the loss does not, by itself, establish that there was a business. [Amicarelli, paragraphs 56–58.]

Lessons from Amicarelli

Amicarelli confirms that the existing principles distinguishing capital from income apply to digital assets. It reminds investors that intention, concrete steps, financing, the holding period and the nature of the asset must be considered together. An activity displaying the characteristics of a business may result in full taxation of its profits and treatment of its losses under the business-loss rules. Property held on capital account is governed by a different regime. This is not a choice to be made after a gain or loss has occurred.

For investors, the practical lesson is to document their approach from the outset: transactions, financing, the intended objective and evidence that can help reconstruct assets and losses. In Amicarelli, gaps in the documentary record made the Court’s assessment of the evidence and testimony necessary. The decision does not mean that every Bitcoin holding is a business or that every platform-related loss is deductible from income. Each situation requires its own analysis. [Amicarelli, paragraphs 45–46 and 58.]

Sources and tax details

The displayed date is separate from the content review date. This article provides general information based on the stated sources and scope of review. It is not tax advice tailored to your situation. The rules, their conditions and administrative positions must be reviewed before taking action.

APPLY THIS TO YOUR SITUATION

Support for your plans.

Investments, real estate and holding corporations

Personal or corporate ownership, financing, securities and real estate: connect investment taxation with your broader wealth plans.

Discuss this topic
Back to short articles